Reporting Standards Authors must report research results honestly, accurately, objectively, and in a replicable manner. Source: COPE (2011); Elsevier (2020).
Originality and Plagiarism Manuscripts must be original and free from plagiarism, with proper citation of all sources. Source: COPE (2011); APA (2020).
Multiple Publication Manuscripts must not be submitted or published in more than one journal simultaneously. Source: ICMJE (2023); COPE (2011).
Data Access and Retention Authors should be prepared to provide and retain research data for a reasonable period. Source: ALPSP–STM (2006); COPE (2019).
Authorship Only those who made significant contributions should be listed as authors and must approve the final version. Source: ICMJE (2023); COPE (2011).
Conflicts of Interest All conflicts of interest and funding sources must be disclosed. Source: COPE (2019); Elsevier (2020).
Post-Publication Errors Significant errors must be promptly reported for correction or retraction. Source: COPE Retraction Guidelines (2019).
Duties of Editors
Fair Play — Editors evaluate manuscripts solely on academic merit. Source: COPE (2011).
Confidentiality — All manuscript information is treated as confidential. Source: COPE (2019).
Conflicts of Interest — Editors must not use unpublished material for personal research. Source: COPE (2011).
Publication Decision — Decisions are based on scholarly quality and relevance. Source: Elsevier (2020); COPE (2011).
Duties of Reviewers
Objectivity — Reviews must be objective and constructive. Source: COPE (2013).
Confidentiality — Manuscripts are confidential documents. Source: COPE (2013).
Conflicts of Interest — Reviewers must decline reviews with conflicts of interest. Source: COPE (2013).
Acknowledgment of Sources — Reviewers should identify uncited relevant work and possible overlap. Source: COPE (2013).